Back to blog
Thursday, April 3, 2025
10 min read

Exploring the Flavors of Saint Helena Through the Ages

Journey through the fascinating culinary history of Saint Helena! Discover the island''s unique blend of flavors, from humble beginnings to modern delights, with iconic dishes and cultural influences.

Are you curious about the culinary secrets of a remote island in the South Atlantic? Saint Helena, a hidden gem with a rich history, offers a unique and captivating food scene. This blog post will transport you through time, unveiling the island’s fascinating culinary journey, from humble beginnings to modern delights. Prepare to tantalize your taste buds with a journey through Saint Helena’s iconic dishes, the cultural forces that shaped its unique identity, and the stories behind its delicious food.

The Colonial Table: Feasts and Famines in Saint Helena

Saint Helena’s early culinary history is inextricably linked to its strategic location as a vital provisioning stop for ships sailing between Europe, Africa, and Asia. Life on this remote island, especially during the period when the British East India Company and later the British Crown held sway, was often a matter of what could be cultivated and what could be brought from passing ships.

  • Common Ingredients: Early settlers relied on grains, primarily wheat and barley, imported by ships. Vegetables like pumpkins, sweet potatoes, and beans were grown in home gardens and farms, as were limited amounts of local fruits. Protein often came from preserved meats from ship’s stores. Seasonality was a major factor, dictated by ship arrivals and availability of supplies. Preservation techniques, such as salting, drying, and pickling, were crucial to extending the shelf life of available foods.
  • Staple Foods: The common folk likely consumed porridges, stews (often containing salted meats and root vegetables), and bread made from imported flour. Meals were simple and often centered around a single pot of food, reflecting the limited resources and challenging conditions on the island, and the need to conserve energy.

In contrast, the food of the elite, including the governor and company officials, was naturally more elaborate.

  • Differences: They enjoyed better access to imported goods like spices, sugar, and preserved meats, and fresh produce from well-tended gardens. More complex food preparation techniques were also employed.
  • Delicacies: The elite enjoyed imported items like fine wines, exotic fruits, and luxury meats. Cooks and servants were employed to create their meals.

Cooking methods during this era relied on basic technology.

  • Methods: Cooking mainly took place over open fires, using cast iron pots and skillets. Baking was performed in communal ovens, and preservation techniques included rudimentary fermentation and pickling methods.

From Humble Beginnings to National Treasures: The Stories Behind Fish Cakes, Peanut Cookies, and Tattie Cakes

Let’s uncover the stories behind three iconic Saint Helenian dishes, exploring their origins, evolution, and cultural significance.

  • Fish Cakes:
    • Origins: Fish cakes, a simple yet satisfying dish, likely originated as a way to utilize the abundant fish available in the surrounding waters. The fish cakes were born out of the necessity to make the food last, and to avoid wasting any of the catch. The island’s location, with ships passing through, also meant that supplies were limited, and cooks would need to stretch whatever ingredients they could. Originally made with salt fish, potatoes, and onions, fish cakes became a common, affordable, and filling meal for many residents. (Search intent: the history of fish cakes, where did fish cakes originate, who invented fish cakes).
    • Evolution: Over time, recipes have evolved, and cooks on the island will use the best fish they have available at the time. The recipe’s simplicity has ensured its survival.
    • Cultural Significance: Fish cakes remain a staple food, enjoyed by islanders of all ages. They’re a common sight at family gatherings, community events, and local festivals. The dish is not only delicious, but serves as a symbol of home and cultural identity.
  • Peanut Cookies:
    • Origins: Peanut cookies, a treat with a unique flavor profile, are believed to have been developed through a combination of the island’s existing recipes and supplies which were sometimes exchanged with passing ships. Saint Helena has a long history of ships, and has always looked to them for supplies, and it is likely these cookies used ingredients from ships. (Search intent: the history of peanut cookies, where did peanut cookies originate, who invented peanut cookies).
    • Evolution: Over time, the recipes have evolved, and peanut cookies are seen frequently at special events.
    • Cultural Significance: Peanut cookies are associated with warmth, hospitality, and celebrations. They are often shared during Christmas time, and other family gatherings.
  • Tattie Cakes:
    • Origins: Tattie cakes, are essentially potato cakes, and are made using potatoes, which were first imported in the 17th century, by the East India Company. (Search intent: the history of Tattie Cakes, where did Tattie Cakes originate, who invented Tattie Cakes).
    • Evolution: While the ingredient has remained the same, the recipes have changed.
    • Cultural Significance: Tattie Cakes, are made often to use up left over mashed potatoes. They are frequently served as snacks or for light meals. They are a testament to the islanders’ resourcefulness and ability to create delicious dishes from available ingredients.

A Melting Pot of Flavors: Cultural Influences on Saint Helena’s Culinary Identity

The unique geographical location of Saint Helena meant that many different cultures could be seen on the island, with some cultures more influential than others.

  • British Influence: The British colonial presence had a major impact on Saint Helenian cuisine. Many dishes, ingredients, and preparation techniques were adapted from British traditions, including the widespread use of root vegetables, meat pies, and roasted meats. Baking practices also reflect British influence, with dishes such as cakes and biscuits becoming staples. (Search intent: how did the British influence St Helena food, St Helena food cultural influences).
  • African Influence: Enslaved Africans brought with them their own culinary traditions, including the cultivation of certain crops and unique cooking techniques. Dishes like vegetable stews and rice-based meals reflect this influence. The blending of British ingredients with African cooking methods has further diversified Saint Helena’s food culture. (Search intent: how did African culture influence St Helena food, St Helena food cultural influences).

Food trade and exchange have also left their mark.

  • Imports: The island’s reliance on imported goods has significantly influenced its cuisine. Spices, sugar, tea, and preserved foods have been introduced and integrated into local recipes, creating unique combinations of flavors. These items impacted dishes and the culinary habits, and were adopted and adapted by local cooks.
  • Exports: Saint Helena, at times, has exported certain ingredients, and used those to further its economy. While not major, the island’s access to trading ships has made it an important element of its culture.

Important Ingredients:

  • Fish: Fish has always been a staple of the Saint Helenian diet. The island’s waters teem with a variety of fish, offering a plentiful source of protein for the inhabitants. Historically, fish has been caught using various methods, from hand-lining to more advanced techniques. The cultural significance of fish extends beyond its nutritional value; it’s central to many traditional dishes and is a symbol of the island’s connection to the sea. (Search intent: history of fish in St Helena, when did St Helena start eating fish).
  • Potatoes: Potatoes were first imported in the 17th century. These versatile tubers have become a staple. Potatoes are used in various dishes, including stews, cakes, and side dishes. (Search intent: history of potatoes in St Helena, when did St Helena start eating potatoes).

A Tapestry of Tastes: Exploring Saint Helena’s Regional Culinary Delights

Even within Saint Helena, you can see that different regions have their own culinary differences.

  • Jamestown: The town is known for its diversity of restaurants and cafes, with the widest selection of international cuisines alongside traditional Saint Helenian dishes.
  • Sandy Bay: Offers a more rural experience, with access to fresh, local ingredients and home-style cooking.

More than Sustenance: Exploring the Role of Food in Saint Helena Society

Food plays a vital role in Saint Helena society, reflecting cultural values.

  • Eating Habits: Saint Helenians typically enjoy three meals a day, but mealtimes can be flexible. The food is often served family-style, with everyone gathering around the table.
  • Social Gatherings: Food is at the heart of celebrations, festivals, and family events. Festivals will feature local food, and families are involved in food production.
  • Traditions: Food-related customs, beliefs, and traditions are often passed down through generations. Many families have their own unique recipes, and food is seen as a way to celebrate heritage and community.

From Past to Present: An Evolving Plate

The Saint Helenian diet has seen changes throughout history.

  • Historical Changes: Throughout history, the Saint Helenian diet has evolved with changes in trade, global events, and political factors.
  • Modern Times: In modern times, there have been more changes. There is an increased focus on local ingredients, and the influence of global food trends.

Five Culinary Curiosities of Saint Helena

  • Saint Helena’s geographical isolation has led to a unique biodiversity, including the production of a wide variety of fruits and vegetables, and the use of locally sourced ingredients in many traditional dishes.
  • The island’s connection to the East India Company meant that ingredients like spices and tea were introduced early on, influencing local cuisine.
  • The island’s cuisine has seen a resurgence in recent times. There has been an increased focus on locally sourced produce and efforts to preserve traditional recipes.
  • Certain types of fish are only caught in specific areas, and some methods of fishing, such as hand-lining are used even today.
  • The island’s food culture reflects its long history and a commitment to preserving local heritage.

Frequently Asked Questions about Saint Helena’s Food History

Is it considered rude to refuse food when offered in Saint Helena?

It is generally considered polite to accept food when offered. It shows respect for your host, but politely declining a second helping is usually acceptable.

Are there any unique spices or herbs used in Saint Helenian cooking?

While not unique to the island, the use of fresh herbs such as thyme, rosemary, and parsley is common, often grown in home gardens.

Where can you find traditional Saint Helenian dishes today?

Some local restaurants and guesthouses still offer traditional dishes, and local markets often sell homemade goods.

Are there any food-related festivals or events celebrated on Saint Helena?

There are occasional food festivals, and food plays a central role in traditional events and celebrations, like the annual Saints’ Day.

What are some resources to learn more about Saint Helena’s culinary history?

There are limited dedicated resources, but historical societies, local museums, and some websites offer insights. Local cook books and travel guides may contain more information.

Conclusion

Saint Helena’s cuisine is a delicious reflection of its fascinating history and unique location. From the simple fare of early settlers to the diverse dishes enjoyed today, its food tells a captivating story of cultural exchange and adaptation. If you have a chance to visit Saint Helena, savour the opportunity to try its authentic cuisine, and experience this hidden gem in person! You can also research recipes, or enjoy foods made in the spirit of Saint Helenian cuisine, and appreciate the flavors and history of this isolated island.