Back to blog
Friday, April 4, 2025
9 min read

Reykjavik Food Guide | Your Insider''s Map to Icelandic Cuisine

Discover the best of Reykjavik's food scene! This guide reveals must-try Icelandic dishes, dining etiquette, unique ingredients, and surprising facts to enhance your culinary adventure.

Planning a trip to the land of fire and ice? Beyond the breathtaking landscapes and the awe-inspiring Northern Lights, Reykjavik boasts a vibrant and unique culinary scene just waiting to be explored. Are you curious about experiencing the best of Icelandic cuisine? This guide is your passport to understanding and enjoying Reykjavik food, from hearty stews to fresh seafood and everything in between. Forget the clichés and be prepared for a truly delicious adventure! We’ll dive into local specialties, dining etiquette, essential ingredients, and even throw in a few fun facts and helpful FAQs to make your foodie adventure in Reykjavik unforgettable. Get ready to eat your way through Iceland!

Delving into the History of Icelandic Cuisine

The history of Icelandic cuisine is deeply intertwined with the island’s harsh climate and limited resources. For centuries, survival depended on preserving food through methods like salting, smoking, and fermenting. Sheep farming and fishing have always been central to the Icelandic diet. The traditional diet consisted primarily of fish, lamb, dairy products (like skyr), and root vegetables. Today, while modern influences are present, Icelandic cuisine still celebrates its rich heritage, offering dishes that reflect the island’s unique environment and history.

Local Specialties: Must-Try Dishes in Reykjavik

Prepare your taste buds for an incredible culinary journey! Here are some iconic Icelandic dishes that you absolutely can’t miss while in Reykjavik:

  • Hákarl (Fermented Shark): (The Icelandic national dish)

    • Description: This pungent delicacy is Greenland shark that has been cured and fermented for several months. It has a strong, ammonia-rich smell and a distinctive, acquired taste. It’s often served in small cubes.
    • Origin/History: Historically, Hákarl was a way of preserving shark meat, as the shark is toxic when fresh. The fermentation process neutralizes the toxins.
  • Kjötsúpa (Icelandic Lamb Soup): (Meat Soup)

    • Description: A hearty and comforting soup made with tender lamb, root vegetables (like carrots and potatoes), and sometimes rice or barley. It’s typically seasoned with herbs and spices.
  • Plokkfiskur (Fish Stew): (Plucked Fish)

    • Description: A creamy and flavorful fish stew made with flaked fish (often cod or haddock), potatoes, onions, and a béchamel sauce. It’s often served with rye bread.
  • Hangikjöt (Smoked Lamb): (Hanged Meat)

    • Description: Smoked lamb, traditionally smoked over birch or sheep dung (though modern methods are more common). It has a rich, smoky flavour and is often thinly sliced and served with flatbread or potatoes and white sauce.
  • Pylsur (Icelandic Hot Dog): (The Icelandic Hot Dog)

    • Description: This is a true Icelandic institution and not to be missed. Made from lamb, pork, and beef, these hot dogs are served in a bun with a variety of toppings, including raw onions, crispy fried onions, remoulade (a mayonnaise-based sauce), and ketchup.
  • Skyr (Skyr): (Skyr)

    • Description: Skyr is a traditional Icelandic dairy product that’s similar to yogurt or a thick cheese. It’s high in protein and has a slightly tangy taste. It can be eaten plain, with fruit, or mixed into other dishes.
  • Rúgbrauð (Icelandic Rye Bread): (Icelandic Rye Bread)

    • Description: A dark, dense, and slightly sweet rye bread traditionally baked in a pot buried in the ground near a geothermal area. It has a distinctive, slightly earthy flavour.

Dining Etiquette and Cultural Norms in Reykjavik

Navigating a new culture can be tricky, but knowing these few simple dining etiquette tips will help you dine like a local in Reykjavik:

  • Tipping: Tipping is not expected in Reykjavik. Service charges are usually included in the bill. However, if you received exceptional service, you can round up the bill or leave a small tip (5-10%) as a gesture of appreciation.

  • Greetings: A simple “Hæ” (Hi) or “Takk” (Thank you) will always be appreciated.

  • Table Manners: Standard Western table manners are followed. Wait for everyone to be served before you start eating, and keep your elbows off the table. If you’re sharing dishes, use serving utensils. It’s polite to try a little bit of everything that is offered.

  • Pace of Dining: Dining in Reykjavik is generally a relaxed affair. Don’t feel rushed. Take your time to enjoy your meal and conversation.

  • Attire: Reykjavik is a casual city. Smart casual attire is appropriate for most restaurants. For fine-dining establishments, a slightly more dressed-up look is recommended, but never required.

  • Dining Times: Lunch is typically between 12:00 PM and 2:00 PM, and dinner is usually between 6:00 PM and 9:00 PM. Restaurants can get busy, especially on weekends, so reservations are recommended, particularly for dinner.

  • Bread and Water: Bread and water are usually complimentary. It is also completely acceptable to ask for more water.

  • Getting the Waiter’s Attention: Icelanders are generally very polite. It’s easy to get the waiter’s attention by making eye contact and saying ‘Afskidi’ which means ‘excuse me’.

  • Conversations: Icelanders are friendly but not overly effusive. General conversation is fine, but avoid sensitive topics like politics or personal finances until you get to know the people.

  • Taking Photos: Taking photos of your food is acceptable, but always ask before taking photos of other diners.

Essential Ingredients in Icelandic Cuisine: A Flavor Profile

The unique flavours of Icelandic cuisine come from a select set of ingredients that thrive in the island’s climate. Understanding these ingredients enhances your appreciation of Reykjavik food:

  • Lamb: (Lamb)

    • Description: Icelandic lamb is known for its tender texture and distinct flavour, due to the sheep grazing freely on natural pastures. It’s used in a variety of dishes, including soups, stews, and roasts.
    • If you can’t find it…: Use high-quality lamb from a trusted butcher or, as a last resort, substitute with good-quality mutton.
  • Seafood (Cod, Salmon, etc.): (Cod, Salmon, etc.)

    • Description: Iceland’s location provides access to incredible fresh seafood, particularly cod, salmon, and haddock. These are prepared in numerous ways – grilled, pan-fried, smoked, or cured.
    • If you can’t find it…: Substitute with the freshest possible fish you can find. If unavailable consider using imported, previously frozen fish, as it is common.
  • Skyr: (Skyr)

    • Description: This unique dairy product is similar to yogurt but thicker and higher in protein. It has a tangy, slightly sour taste and is used in various ways, from breakfast to desserts.
    • If you can’t find it…: Substitute with Greek yogurt, but be aware that the flavour and texture are slightly different.
  • Rúgbrauð: (Icelandic Rye Bread)

    • Description: This dark, dense rye bread, often baked in geothermal areas, has a unique slightly sweet and earthy flavour. It is often enjoyed with butter or smoked meats.
    • If you can’t find it…: Use a high-quality, dense rye bread. If this is not possible, a heavy wholemeal bread will work, although the flavour will be different.
  • Wild Berries (Blueberries, Crowberries, etc.): (Wild Berries)

    • Description: Iceland is home to a variety of wild berries, including blueberries, crowberries, and bilberries. They are used in jams, desserts, and as garnishes.
    • If you can’t find it…: Use blueberries or a mix of berries. You may also be able to find frozen Icelandic blueberries in specialist shops.

Unveiling 5 Surprising Facts about Reykjavik and Icelandic Food Culture

Here are some interesting facts about Reykjavik and Icelandic food to add some extra flavor to your adventure:

Reykjavik holds the title of the world’s northernmost capital city, offering a unique blend of cosmopolitan culture and Arctic charm.

The Blue Lagoon geothermal spa is a popular attraction, famous for its mineral-rich, milky-blue waters.

Iceland boasts a strong literary tradition, and the Icelandic Sagas are an integral part of its heritage.

Iceland maintains a very low crime rate, making it one of the safest countries on Earth.

Hallgrímskirkja church, with its unique architecture inspired by basalt columns, is a landmark visible from all parts of the city.

Frequently Asked Questions About Dining in Reykjavik

Are reservations required at most restaurants in Reykjavik?

Yes, reservations are highly recommended, particularly for dinner and at popular restaurants, especially during peak season. It is also recommended for lunch at weekends, and for many events.

Is the tap water safe to drink in Reykjavik?

Absolutely! Reykjavik’s tap water is some of the purest in the world, sourced directly from natural springs. It’s perfectly safe and delicious to drink.

What’s the best way to find authentic local food markets in Reykjavik?

There are not a huge amount of authentic local food markets, but try visiting Kolaportið Flea Market on weekends for a taste of local produce and treats. You can find local food at various shops in downtown Reykjavik. Many are happy to chat about their wares.

Are there any food-related festivals in Reykjavik I should know about?

Yes! Consider checking out the Reykjavik Food Festival and the Beer Day Festival for a delicious local cuisine experience.

How do I ask for the bill in Icelandic?

You can say, “Greiða, takk” (Pronounced: gray-tha tak) meaning “Pay, please.” or more commonly just say “Reikningur, takk”, meaning ‘bill please’

Conclusion: Savoring the Flavors of Reykjavik

From the challenging Hákarl to the comforting Kjötsúpa and the iconic Pylsur, Reykjavik’s food scene is a journey for the senses. Hopefully, this guide has given you a taste of what to expect and some useful Reykjavik food tips for your adventure. Now, go forth and explore this vibrant city and enjoy the deliciousness! What is your favourite Icelandic dish? Share it in the comments! Happy eating!